When you’re two tops in love trying to win a sword fight

Add this share
Two tops don’t necessarily make a wrong. What may be in order is more fun, less categorizing, and a whole lot of communication.


I’ve been with my boyfriend for almost a year, and for the first time in my life, I’m not questioning whether the love is real. We are definitely connected on a higher level than I’ve ever experienced.

There is one hitch, though: We’re both tops. We click on every level but that one.

I’ve bottomed a couple times, but when I bring up reciprocation, we argue. When I’m not willing to do it, it’s like a sword fight down there. I don’t want to be in this stalemate forever, and I definitely don’t want to lose this relationship.

Dear Labelmaker:

Confrontation breeds nothing but defense, so you can’t argue your way into unchartered sexual territory. Conversation is a much better tack, and not-in-the-moment is a much better time.

The first thing to discuss as honestly and openly as possible is whether what you are after is even a possibility for him. There are ways to live with “no” and maintain your relationship, but if you act like “no” means “maybe” or “with the right strategy,” you’ve got bigger issues than sex in your relationship.

If you’re in the land of “absolutely not,” it may be a deal breaker for some couples, and that can be a harsh truth. But long before you end up at that crossroads, try learning to love the “sword fight.” Focus on other sexual situations you both enjoy, or entertain a third who loves bottoming. Those are just just a couple of options. Stop focusing on the problem and turn your minds toward solutions.

If he’s willing to share bottom duty at least sometimes, there are some things you can both do. Hone your thinking and your activity to make the process of getting there smoother and more fun. Anyone interested in receptive anal sex who is scared can help themselves and each other with a few suggestions.

Forget labels. “I’m not going to be the bottom in this relationship” triggers every emotional hot button on both sides, not to mention puts negative stigma on bottoming. What if no one was a “top” or a “bottom” and everyone just wanted to have sex? Make it about desire.

Tap your sexual super powers. What turns him on about you? Ask him and give it to him. If it’s your chest, walk around shirtless more. The noises you make in bed? Make more. Have him do your stuff too, and everyone will feel more attractive and attracted.

Emphasize reciprocity. Partners don’t just do things to each other in bed, they do things for each other.

Commit to consider. First, you commit to not even try topping him, as he openly considers the possibility. The lack of pressure “in the moment” takes the anxiety of anticipation out of the equation. Trust is a key issue. Don’t violate it.

Simulation stimulation. Even if you never get in the back door, you can both have a lot of fun in the neighborhood. Without ever penetrating each other, discover the joys of rimming and frottaging, the fancy term for your proverbial “sword fight” and its sexual friction.

Try it. After a period of the above steps and a thorough cleansing — and based solely on his schedule — give penetration a shot. To support an environment of zero pressure, put in place caveats that false starts, time outs and rainchecks are totally OK.

Q Advice is intended for entertainment, not counseling. Send your burning Qs to [email protected].

Illustration by Brad Gibson

A version of this column also appeared in Q ATLus magazine. Read the issue here:

Pick us up each week at LGBTQ and allied venues, and find new content here every day.


Political pundit Robin Biro wants to be Tucker’s first LGBTQ mayor

Real estate consultant, political strategist and retired U.S. Army ranger Robin Biro is taking his years of Democratic Party activism to the ballot and...

Pandemic leaves boyfriends ‘stuck together and sticking it out’

We joked all winter that we met during cuffing season, and that cuddling through cold nights would be nice only while they lasted. Well, spring is here.

Athens, Columbus near passage of broad LGBTQ protections

Two of Georgia’s six largest cities stand poised to adopt sweeping LGBTQ-inclusive nondiscrimination ordinances, bringing protections to some 300,000 more residents. But a similar effort...

Friends and fans turn out for Lily White memorial

What becomes a legend? When the legend is Lily White, it’s a roomful of faithful followers to remember the life of one of Atlanta’s...

10 ways to help cure those summertime blues

Cruel summer? Summer SADs are an actual thing. Try these 10 things to help re-frame the summertime blues when the thrill of Stonewall Month and freshness of pool parties are gone.