Need Wood? The raw truth barebacking debate

Add this share
READ MORE | Catch up on all the Need Wood? columns on Project Q Atlanta

If friends, even doctors, tell you that tops who bareback are at as much risk of HIV as guys giving unprotected oral sex, you need to switch doctors and get new friends. Setting the record straight.

Hey Mike!
imageYou recently said that bareback topping is the No. 2 avenue for HIV infection, with bareback bottoming being No. 1. That statement concerns me.

My physician is a prominent gay doctor, and I am a personal friend with another physician. Both have told me the same thing: The chances of a bare backing (BB) top — strictly top, not one that bottoms occasionally—being infected with HIV is equal to the risk of unprotected oral sex — taking cum in the mouth and swallowing.

My physician goes so far to say that bottoming with a condom is no riskier than being a bareback top! With the exceptions that condoms can leak and break and assuming the top doesn’t have open sores on his penis.

Now both doctors qualify this by saying they don’t want to give the impression that a BB top is safe, but they also concede that gay men have a misconception that oral sex is safe, when the fact is there are documented cases of HIV transmission through oral sex, a fact that some gay men still want to deny. Both don’t encourage BB topping or unprotected oral sex.

I think the gay community needs to be properly informed. While the risk of BB topping is extremely low, in reality it’s no riskier than unprotected oral sex.?
— Straightening you out

Dear Straightening:
imageYou need a new doctor and better friends. Any doctor who says that the risk of topping without a condom is equal to giving oral sex needs their license to say “beautician,” not “Doctor of Medicine.”

As long as there are no scrapes, cuts or abrasions in your mouth, the risk of giving oral sex is minimal. But the risk of topping somebody who’s positive is much greater, even if you don’t have any sores or cuts on your penis.

Here’s why: As you thrust, the urethra is stretched open, allowing fecal matter, blood particles and other delicious goodies to enter. As you pull out for the next thrusts, the urethral opening closes, pushing all those goodies deeper, possibly scratching or tearing the urethra and creating a transmission route.

Contrast that to giving head. Somebody thrusts himself into your mouth. If there are no scratches or abrasions in either his penis or your mouth, how can the virus enter your bloodstream? There is the possibility that it could be absorbed through the soft lining of the mouth’s membranes, but there’s also the possibility that I’ll go on a date without putting out. The odds are about the same: next to nothing.

Let me tell you a parable that speaks to your doctor’s prominent stupidity:

During the debt ceiling talks, House Speaker John Boehner sent President Obama a letter. Obama opened the letter and it contained a message that was obviously in code:


Obama couldn’t figure out the code, so he sent it to the CIA. They couldn’t solve it, so it went to the NSA, the FBI, MIT, NASA and finally to the Secret Service. Eventually, they asked an elderly WWII code breaker. The guy took one look at it and said, “Tell the president he is looking at the message upside down.”

That’s a long way of saying your doctor is looking at HIV research upside down. Hand it to him right side up and get a new doctor.

imageContributing blogger Mike Alvear is an Atlanta-based columnist, author and TV personality. Dating life in the dirt? Download his ebooks, “Attract Hotter Guys with the Secrets & Science of Sexual Body Language,” and “Attract Hotter Guys Online: The Secrets To Making Yourself Irresistible on Gay Dating Sites.” Have a question for Need Wood? Just {encode=”[email protected]” title=”send it in”}.


10 people you never, ever want to date again

You know them. Maybe you loved them. Just say no to the these 10 LGBTQ people who we never, ever want to date again.   Bitter &...

The best LGBTQ things to do in Atlanta this weekend

Shows, sports and other queer shenanigans top a busy list of Atlanta events for LGBTQ and allied weekenders. Keep scrolling and click on each event...

Gender nonconforming person beaten, puppy stolen in Midtown

An armed robber pistol-whipped a 53-year-old gender nonconforming person in his Midtown home last month then stole the victim's puppy. The suspect is still...

Q ATLus catches Atlanta dreaming of Pride Weekend

Every last one of us will probably take a different route to celebrating Pride 2021, and that’s OK. With love in their hearts and safety...

Atlanta at center of jump in anti-LGBTQ hate crimes

Two-thirds of the 28 anti-LGBTQ hate crimes reported in Georgia by the FBI in 2020 occurred in metro Atlanta. The number of overall hate crimes...