Critics of religious freedom bills dissed as absurd

Add this share

Move aside, Mike Bowers. Supporters of “religious freedom” legislation in the Georgia Legislature fired back at the Republican former attorney general with their own slate of legal experts lauding the anti-gay bills.

A slate of 14 law professors, from Harvard to Notre Dame and the University of Virginia, offered their analysis of state Rep. Sam Teasley's House Bill 218. The conclusion? Bowers and other LGBT opponents of the legislation are making “absurd claims.”

Via the AJC:

Curiously, Teasley’s experts say the bill might not offer protection to small businesses seeking to duck gay marriage. A few choice paragraphs:

Opponents of these bills often make absurd claims about the extreme results they would allegedly produce, but they have no examples of judicial decisions actually reaching such results. In the places where this standard applies, it has not been interpreted in crazy ways that have caused problems for those jurisdictions; if anything, these laws have been enforced too cautiously. Litigants can argue anything, but the general experience with Religious Freedom Restoration Acts has been under enforcement, not over enforcement….

Much of the opposition to HB 218 appears to center on the fear that religious owners of for-profit businesses might use the state RFRA as a shield against discrimination claims. The only prominent case involved a Christian wedding photographer who was sued after refusing to photograph a same-sex commitment ceremony, believing she would thereby be promoting an immoral act deeply at odds with her religious understanding of the meaning of marriage and of weddings. See Elane Photography v. Willock, 309 P.3d 53 (N.M. 2013).

For many religious believers, weddings are inherently religious events in which their participation must conform to religious obligations. There are serious arguments for exempting religious individuals who personally provide creative services to assist with weddings. But whatever one thinks of those arguments, it is far from clear that HB 218 would lead courts to recognize such an exemption.

The response form Teasley came a day after Bowers – the former attorney general who fought LGBT issues during his four terms – sided with LGBT activists in denouncing that bill and Sen. Josh McKoon's similar S.B. Bill 129.

“This legislation is not about gay marriage, or contraception, or even so-called 'religious freedom,'” Bowers wrote in his analysis. “It is more important than all of these, because it ultimately involves the rule of law. Regardless of whether one agrees with a particular policy, or if it offends one’s religious sensibilities, the proposed [Religious Freedom Restoration Act] is bad for all Georgians of good faith, or for that matter, of any faith whatsoever. It is not just bad public policy; it is ill-conceived, unnecessary, mean-spirited and deserving of a swift death in the General Assembly.”

Meanwhile, McKoon remains optimistic about his bill.

THE LATEST

WSB’s Jorge Estevez’s secret to surviving the pandemic? Snacks

Jorge Estevez moved to Atlanta to start his new job just weeks before the coronavirus pandemic hit, then racial justice protests unfolded and a...

Massive expansion of ‘Church’ bar finally open after 2020 plot twists

Grant Henry’s vision is always unique, his dreams always big, and the quirky results always undeniable. Patrons see that dynamic in action again with...

10 gender identities to know and respect beyond the binary

Between, beside and beyond the binary come those people who identify outside the traditional male and female roles and expectations.

Q ATLus looks at defining our own LGBTQ love stories

The impulse to hop the marriage train has been in full force in some LGBTQ circles for five years, but a growing chorus of...

Noni’s staff quarantined together to make partial reopening safe

“Honey, we are dyyyyinggggg to open our doors wide open and have a dance party again, but we aren’t even close to that yet,”...
17,355FansLike
5,772FollowersFollow
7,596FollowersFollow

MOST POPULAR

Events

0
Sister Louisa's Church of the Living Room and Ping Pong Emporium 2020

Massive expansion of ‘Church’ bar finally open after 2020 plot twists

0
Grant Henry’s vision is always unique, his dreams always big, and the quirky results always undeniable. Patrons see that dynamic in action again with...

Index, ring fingers tell the secret of your penis

0
The next time you’re cruising Mr. Right Now, take a gander at his index and ring fingers. The difference between the two predicts what you’ll find when the package gets unwrapped. Less is more. Really.

Georgia LGBTQ leaders endorse Biden as pro-equality ‘champion’

0
Eleven LGBTQ leaders from metro Atlanta joined some 300 others nationwide to endorse Joe Biden and Kamala Harris, calling them “the most pro-equality ticket...

10 gender identities to know and respect beyond the binary

0
Between, beside and beyond the binary come those people who identify outside the traditional male and female roles and expectations.

Q ATLus looks at defining our own LGBTQ love stories

0
The impulse to hop the marriage train has been in full force in some LGBTQ circles for five years, but a growing chorus of...

PHOTO GALLERIES